=============================== File 6HCMP32.TXT Comparison of Detection Quality of 32-Bit Scanning Engines: (Win-98 / Win-NT / Win-2000) =============================== Formatted with non-proportional font (Courier) The following tables summarize the respective detection rates of products on different 32-bit platforms (Windows 98, Windows-NT, and Windows-2000 respectively, concerning products with results on ALL platforms). Products with identical detection quality for both instantiations of 32-bit engines are marked with "*". Comparative tables: ------------------- Table Comp.F1v: Detection of Zoo File viruses Table Comp.F1f: Detection of Zoo File viral files Table Comp.F2v: Detection of ITW File viruses Table Comp.F2f: Detection of ITW File viral files Table Comp.F3m: Detection of Zoo File Malware Table Comp.M1v: Detection of Zoo Macro viruses Table Comp.M1f: Detection of Zoo Macro viral files Table Comp.M2v: Detection of ITW Macro viruses Table Comp.M2f: Detection of ITW Macro viral files Table Comp.M3m: Detection of Zoo File Malware Table Comp.S1v: Detection of Zoo Script viruses Table Comp.S1f: Detection of Zoo Script viral files Table Comp.S2v: Detection of ITW Script viruses Table Comp.S2f: Detection of ITW Script viral files Table Comp.F1v: Detection Quality of Zoo File Viruses: ====================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match ------------------------------------------------------------ AV3 19581 95.2 19540 95.0 19581 95.2 AVG 16851 81.9 16851 81.9 16851 81.9 * AVK 20518 99.8 20518 99.8 20518 99.8 * AVP 20539 99.9 20540 99.9 20538 99.9 CMD 20111 97.8 20110 97.8 20110 97.8 FPR 20111 97.8 20111 97.8 20111 97.8 * FPW 20108 97.8 20108 97.8 20108 97.8 * INO 20107 97.8 20122 97.9 20126 97.9 NAV 19307 93.9 19309 93.9 19308 93.9 NVC 20173 98.1 20173 98.1 20173 98.1 * PAV 20539 99.9 20045 97.5 20508 99.7 PRO 14500 70.5 14509 70.6 14376 69.9 RAV 19231 93.5 19231 93.5 19239 93.6 SCN 20515 99.8 18294 89.0 20515 99.8 VSP 15313 74.5 2492 12.1 13355 64.9 -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F1f: Detection Quality of Zoo File viral files: ========================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 145286 96.4 144788 96.1 145285 96.4 AVG 129336 85.8 129336 85.8 129336 85.8 * AVK 150530 99.9 150530 99.9 150530 99.9 * AVP 150590 99.9 150592 99.9 150582 99.9 CMD 148734 98.7 148731 98.7 148731 98.7 FPR 148739 98.7 148739 98.7 148739 98.7 * FPW 148736 98.7 148736 98.7 148736 98.7 * INO 148296 98.4 148430 98.5 148367 98.4 NAV 143110 95.0 143141 95.0 143133 95.0 NVC 148195 98.3 148195 98.3 148196 98.3 PAV 150590 99.9 147270 97.7 150475 99.8 PRO 104829 69.6 104852 69.6 103407 68.6 RAV 139144 92.3 139144 92.3 139649 92.7 SCN 150640 100.0 133818 88.8 150640 100.0 VSP 102296 67.9 18467 12.3 90992 60.4 -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2v: Detection Quality of ITW File Viruses: ===================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 19 95.0 19 95.0 20 100.00 AVG 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * AVK 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * AVP 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * CMD 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * FPR 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * FPW 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * FSE 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * INO 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * NAV 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * NVC 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * PAV 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * PER 14 70.0 14 70.0 14 70.00 * PRO 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * RAV 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * SCN 20 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.00 * VSP 9 45.0 9 45.0 9 45.00 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F2f: Detection Quality of ITW File viral files: ========================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 398 97.3 398 97.3 409 100.0 AVG 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * AVK 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * AVP 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * CMD 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * FPR 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * FPW 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * FSE 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * INO 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * NAV 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * NVC 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * PAV 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * PER 235 57.5 235 57.5 235 57.5 * PRO 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * RAV 402 98.3 404 98.8 404 98.8 SCN 409 100.0 409 100.0 409 100.0 * VSP 295 72.1 295 72.1 295 72.1 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.F3m: Detection Quality of Zoo File Malware: ====================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 3185 51.0 2902 46.4 3185 51.0 AVG 3173 50.8 3173 50.8 3172 50.8 AVK 6009 96.1 6009 96.1 6009 96.1 * AVP 6024 96.4 6024 96.4 6020 96.3 CMD 5867 93.9 5872 94.0 5867 93.9 FPR 5872 94.0 5872 94.0 5872 94.0 * FPW 5872 94.0 5872 94.0 5872 94.0 * FSE 6172 98.8 6172 98.8 6007 96.1 INO 4797 76.8 4961 79.4 4797 76.8 NAV 4053 64.8 4053 64.8 4053 64.8 * NVC 4701 75.2 4965 79.4 4965 79.4 PAV 6016 96.3 5756 92.1 5912 94.6 PER 634 10.1 634 10.1 634 10.1 * PRO 2071 33.1 2074 33.2 2074 33.2 RAV 5038 80.6 5038 80.6 5042 80.7 SCN 5653 90.4 5588 89.4 5653 90.4 VSP 2162 34.6 2745 43.9 2745 43.9 -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Viruses: ======================================================= ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 5966 95.7 5966 95.7 5967 95.7 AVG 6128 98.3 6128 98.3 6128 98.3 * AVK 6230 100.0 6230 100.0 6230 100.0 * AVP 6230 100.0 6230 100.0 6230 100.0 * CMD 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 * FPR 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 * FPW 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 * FSE 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 * INO 6215 99.7 6215 99.7 6215 99.7 * NAV 6043 97.0 6043 97.0 6043 97.0 * NVC 6219 99.8 6219 99.8 6219 99.8 * PAV 6230 100.0 6198 99.4 6199 99.5 PER 4252 68.2 4248 68.2 4270 68.5 PRO 4181 67.1 4181 67.1 4181 67.1 * RAV 6208 99.6 6208 99.6 6208 99.6 * SCN 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 6233 100.0 * VSP 1 0.0 1 0.0 1 0.0 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro viral files: =========================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 18651 96.2 18651 96.2 18655 96.2 AVG 19123 98.6 19123 98.6 19123 98.6 * AVK 19380 100.0 19380 100.0 19380 100.0 * AVP 19380 100.0 19381 100.0 19380 100.0 CMD 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 * FPR 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 * FPW 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 * FSE 19387 100.0 19388 100.0 19388 100.0 INO 19334 99.7 19336 99.7 19334 99.7 NAV 18717 96.5 18717 96.5 18717 96.5 * NVC 19333 99.7 19333 99.7 19333 99.7 * PAV 19380 100.0 19275 99.4 19278 99.4 PER 13122 67.7 13105 67.6 13180 68.0 PRO 12125 62.5 12125 62.5 12125 62.5 * RAV 19309 99.6 19309 99.6 19310 99.6 SCN 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 19387 100.0 * VSP 1 0.0 1 0.0 1 0.0 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro Viruses: ======================================================= ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * AVG 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * AVK 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * AVP 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * CMD 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * FPR 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * FPW 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * FSE 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * INO 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * NAV 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * NVC 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * PAV 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * PER 114 77.6 114 77.6 114 77.6 * PRO 146 99.3 146 99.3 146 99.3 * RAV 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * SCN 147 100.0 147 100.0 147 100.0 * VSP 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro viral files: ========================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 1339 99.40 1339 99.4 1339 99.40 * AVG 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * AVK 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * AVP 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * CMD 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * FPR 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * FPW 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * FSE 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * INO 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * NAV 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * NVC 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * PAV 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * PER 1119 83.10 1119 83.1 1119 83.10 * PRO 1315 97.60 1315 97.6 1315 97.60 * RAV 1346 99.90 1346 99.9 1346 99.90 * SCN 1347 100.00 1347 100.0 1347 100.00 * VSP 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.00 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware: ======================================================= ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 329 81.6 329 81.6 329 81.6 * AVG 323 80.1 323 80.1 323 80.1 * AVK 400 99.3 400 99.3 400 99.3 * AVP 400 99.3 400 99.3 400 99.3 * CMD 402 99.8 402 99.8 402 99.8 * FPR 402 99.8 402 99.8 402 99.8 * FSE 403 100.0 403 100.0 403 100.0 * INO 378 93.8 397 98.5 378 93.8 NAV 306 75.9 306 75.9 306 75.9 * NVC 399 99.0 399 99.0 399 99.0 * PAV 400 99.3 399 99.0 400 99.3 PER 234 58.1 234 58.1 234 58.1 * PRO 208 51.6 208 51.6 208 51.6 * RAV 391 97.0 391 97.0 391 97.0 * SCN 403 100.0 403 100.0 402 99.8 VSP 1 0.2 1 0.2 1 0.2 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Viruses: ======================================================== ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 139 29.1 139 29.1 143 30.0 AVG 276 57.9 276 57.9 276 57.9 * AVK 476 99.8 476 99.8 476 99.8 * AVP 476 99.8 476 99.8 476 99.8 * CMD 462 96.9 462 96.9 462 96.9 * FPR 463 97.1 462 96.9 462 96.9 FPW 462 96.9 462 96.9 462 96.9 * FSE 477 100.0 477 100.0 477 100.0 * INO 442 92.7 444 93.1 442 92.7 NAV 260 54.5 260 54.5 260 54.5 * NVC 422 88.5 422 88.5 422 88.5 * PER 105 22.0 105 22.0 105 22.0 * PRO 171 35.8 194 40.7 194 40.7 RAV 405 84.9 405 84.9 405 84.9 * SCN 477 100.0 477 100.0 477 100.0 * VSP 407 85.3 407 85.3 407 85.3 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script viral files: ============================================================ ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 328 36.30 328 36.3 344 38.1 AVG 618 68.40 618 68.4 621 68.7 AVK 901 99.70 901 99.7 901 99.7 * AVP 901 99.70 901 99.7 897 99.2 CMD 850 94.00 850 94.0 850 94.0 * FPR 853 94.40 850 94.0 850 94.0 FPW 846 93.60 846 93.6 846 93.6 * FSE 899 99.40 899 99.4 899 99.4 * INO 831 91.90 835 92.4 831 91.9 NAV 501 55.40 501 55.4 506 56.0 NVC 773 85.50 773 85.5 773 85.5 * PER 214 23.70 214 23.7 214 23.7 * PRO 312 34.50 371 41.0 371 41.0 RAV 697 77.10 697 77.1 697 77.1 * SCN 904 100.00 904 100.0 904 100.0 * VSP 701 77.50 701 77.5 701 77.5 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script Viruses: ========================================================= ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * AVG 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * AVK 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * AVP 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * CMD 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * FPR 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * FPW 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * FSE 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * INO 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * NAV 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * NVC 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * PER 13 81.3 13 81.3 13 81.3 * PRO 14 87.5 16 100.0 16 100.0 SCN 16 100.0 16 100.0 16 100.0 * VSP 14 87.5 14 87.5 14 87.5 * -------------------------------------------------------------- Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script viral files: ============================================================ ====== Detection Quality ========= W32 results Scanner Win-NT % Win-2k % Win-98 % match -------------------------------------------------------------- AV3 119 89.5 119 89.5 121 91.0 AVG 123 92.5 123 92.5 124 93.2 AVK 133 100.0 133 100.0 133 100.0 * AVP 133 100.0 133 100.0 131 98.5 CMD 127 95.5 127 95.5 127 95.5 * FPR 127 95.5 127 95.5 127 95.5 * FPW 123 92.5 123 92.5 123 92.5 * FSE 128 96.2 128 96.2 128 96.2 * INO 132 99.2 133 100.0 132 99.2 NAV 127 95.5 127 95.5 129 97.0 NVC 127 95.5 127 95.5 127 95.5 * PER 82 61.7 82 61.7 82 61.7 * PRO 99 74.4 108 81.2 108 81.2 SCN 133 100.0 133 100.0 133 100.0 * VSP 108 81.2 108 81.2 108 81.2 * --------------------------------------------------------------